ENVISIONING ABUNDANCE FOR THE NEXT DECADE
OPEN SPACE EVENT
FIRST UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST CHURCH OF COLUMBUS
SEPTEMBER 29 – 30, 2007
Including Board Visioning Summary, May, 2007
And
Visioning For the Next Decade by Rev. Mark Belletini and Rev. Wendy Fish
Remarks delivered at the Fellowship Dinner, September 15, 2007
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Attendees at Open Space Technology event 3
Open Space Topics 4
Saturday Sessions
Deeper Youth and Adult Enrichment Programs 5
Social Justice 7
Future Staffing 9
Retaining Youth and Young Adults 11
Welcoming All 13
Creating Abundance 14
Church Health Issues 15
Changing the Name of the Church 16
Effective Communication 17
Handcrafting as Spiritual Practice 18
All Adult Programming 19
Year Round Programming 21
Volunteer/Membership Coordinator 23
Assuring Fiscal Resources 24
Performing Arts 25
Sunday Summary – Chas Williams, recorder 26
Sunday Summary – Chris Kloth, Facilitator 29
Board Visioning Notes, May, 2007 – Doug Zelinski, recorder 44
OPEN SPACE ATTENDEES – SEPTEMBER 29 – 30, 2007
FIRST UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST CHURCH OF COLUMBUS
Rev. Wendy Fish Trish Hultz
Chas Williams Bill Fullerton
Susan Williams Barb Pratzner
Kevin O’Neill Eve Catus
Tom Baillieul Tom Tucker
Olwen Firstone Shikha Bangia
Jim Pinkham
Lydia Delphia
Tony Skrabak
Tina Price
Stephanie Mesler-Evans
Caroline Balderston Parry
Jean Werts
Diana Del Bianco
Jeannie Sperling
Alice Rathburn
Frank Phillips
Dan Hronek
Gretchen Faulstich
Leslie Partridge
Judith McDowell
Carole Pruiksma
Patricia Boughton
Debra Gray Boyd
Julie Henderson
Michael Brennan
Adrian Winchell
Kate Power
Susan Vierow
Carolee Noonan
David Krohn
Karen McGuire
Susan Collis
Steve Abbott
David Easter
Carl Faulstich
Edie Driskil
Mark Merchant
Wendy Boortz
Marilyn Webster
Jim Bailey
Maddie Pinsonneault
Marc Pinsonneault
Open Space, September 29 and 30, 2007, First Unitarian Church of Columbus.
The15 session titles as transcribed by Chris Kloth:
What would it take to become a richly diverse church, David combined with What should be the vision & mission guiding social justice work in our congregation B Fullarton
How do we assure fiscal resources $ for our programs? Chas W.
Year Round Programming - Worship & RE
Volunteer Coordinator Jim P
Increase performing arts support / How can we implement theatre & dance for community building & spirituality David K / Step me (sorry illegible name)
How can we be truly welcoming to all, including children & seniors
Round 2 focus / Direction Health - Personal & Community
How can all adult programming (ouside sunday worship) be coordinated, integrated, improved? Carline BP
How do we integrate & retain youth & young adults Gretchen F
Handcrafting for community building & meditation Steph M
Could name of this place be something other than "Church"?
Communication inside & outside the congregation Tom Tucker
Youth ministry expand? hire staff? depen?
How do we see our professional staffing plan? Chas W.
How do we create abundance
Note that some of these may have either 'not happened' or didn't have notes transcribed.
Openspace Technology Workshop
9-29-2007
---------
Session : 3
Conv : Caroline Balderston PArry
Part : Sue Vierow <gvierow@columbus.rr.com>
Maddie Pinsonneault <pinsonneault.5@osu.edu
Marc Pinsonneault <pinsonneault.1@osu.edu>
Stephanie Mesler-Evans <meslerevans@gmail.com
Lydia Delphia <lydiayak@gmail.com>
Shikha Bangia <munish_shikha@yahoo.com
Carl Faulstich <carlebf@columbus.rr.com
Topics : Sunday AM programming
Go to church service?
Need a room
Now - Every other week AM - Covenant Group + positive youth involvement + adult involement
- Other weeks evening
Covenant Group?
- Does the structure work for this age group?
- Young adults find the structure artificial
listening is fine, but the rules are too rigid
Schedule - every week ( events are important )
Should covenant groups ( closed ) meet at a different time to preserve openspace on Sunday AM?
Training Advisors - done, needed=
Clarifying remarks from Caroline Balderston Parry: I want to clarify some points I was involved in making on Sunday --our group talked about how to have adult programming that goes "beyond covenant groups", after people have had that experience and might not want to go to divinity school and train for the ministry, but want to go deeper, etc. What might we offer that could, for instance, be a one or 2 year program of spiritual practice, guidance, group support, retreats, and so forth? As we spoke on that day, i couldn't remember specific examples of this concept, but now have at least 2 or 3 in mind, and may have printed materials to back me up if you are interested. So here's my list today, and I hope it can be incorporated in some way:
1. Eno River Church (? in TN or VA?) has elaborate programming to meet mental, spiritual and physical needs for growth and depth
2. the Minneapolis UU congregation (or the bigger one of them) has something for a 3 year cycle called "Quest", I think, where participants meet with a minister, get paired up with a spiritual director, undertake a sp.practice for a certain time, and generally prepare to take more spiritual leadership in the congregation and their lives
3. Rochester UU are running a program called "Wellspring" and they led a workshop at GA about it --I have a dear college friend there who is one of the leaders working with the assoc. minister, I think, to administer it, and I got to visit an intro session for "Wellspring" there last spring. She gave me handouts, and I gave copies to Wendy --it's a year long program, and definitely more of a commitment than a Cov Gp, but I can't remember details. However, they aren't that far away and feeling evangelistic, so might even be willing to come share what they do with us
In any case, as Interim, I want to lift up the fact that yu/we have Adult Enrichment Programs here, with the new leadership development classes, and you/we have Covenant Groups and the Path 2 Membs classes, even the choirs are a kind of Adult Enrichment, but there's no coordination for all these different aspects of adult programming, and that's a place where I think this congregation could usefully grow.
Caroline Balderston Parry
Interim Director of Religious Education
First Unitarian Universalist Church of Columbus
93 W. Weisheimer Dr.
Columbus OH 43214
614-267-4946 ext. 28
Social Justice Mission/Vision ideas combined with Diversity
Convenor: Bill Fullarton, Recorder: Diana Del Bianco
Attendees: Bill Fullarston, Diana Del Bianco, Barb Pratzner, David Easter, Susan Williams, Steve Abbott, Tony Skrabak?
Social Justice Mission/Vision brainstorming
Anti-racism, anti-oppression, classism—becoming aware of how we contribute to the problems
Conflict safe dialogue—conflict transformation teams—creative solutions
Range of ways to participate in Social Justice activities
Mobilize congregation around central issues
Connecting with local, national and international Social Justice issues
Need education and empowerment with a spiritual connection
What does Social Justice interaction look like, the spiritual versus the practical side of Social Justice work.
Better integration of various aspects of the spiritual into Social Justice.
Better use of UUA resources
The Social Justice Handbook (the board chair has 10 copies to share)
JUUST Change –UUA consultants who will work with congregations to assess their social justice programs
Participation within congregation at all five levels of Social Justice involvement
Giving (social justice offering)
Serving (volunteering)
Witnessing (writing letters, signing petitions, attending Bread rallies)
Advocating (educating others)
Organizing (mobilizing others)
Possible Social Justice Coordinator
Home for women under Social Justice—support groups/identify demographics within the church, leadership opportunities, create a climate of acceptance.
How do we share space with those who belong to First UU but are of different opinions? How do we accommodate a spectrum of ideas and avoid silencing minority opinions?
Social Justice survey
Social Justice needs to be connected to the spiritual life of the church.
Technology—how to use for Social Justice, how to use to make community action and advocacy opportunities available?
Diversity Focus
Culture—who are we, what are our demographics? (haven’t review this since the last ministerial search)
Internal audit evaluating institutional racism/oppression
Homogenous population
How did this happen?
Class, race, economic status
Eliminating conflict
Fair wage, fair housing
How do we learn to go out to contribute and participate in a diverse world instead of waiting for diversity to come to us? Do we expect others to validate our need to feel diverse?
How do we become the change we wish to see in the world? Then maybe we will attract a more diverse membership.
UUA can assist congregations in discovering the demographics of their communities. Extensive reports can be purchased for under $300 from a service that has a working relationship with UUA.
Awarenesses (ideas we went back and highlighted):
Conflict safe dialogue—conflict transformation teams—creative solutions
Range of ways to participate in Social Justice activities
Home for women under Social Justice—support groups/identify demographics within the church, leadership opportunities, create a climate of acceptance.
Summary:
What would a Social Justice Vision look like:
Acceptance within differences to achieve social justice goals
Integration of spiritual with advocacy dimension of UUism
Social Justice as a spiritual practice
Be agents for the change we want to see in the world
Variety of opportunities for commitment
Actions:
Demographic survey (was this suppose to be internal or external?)
Possible internal audit of our own policies
Expand ways to participate in Social Justice
Openspace Technology Workshop
9-29-2007
---------
Session : 3 Future Staffing
Conv : Chas Williams
Part : Eve Catus
Jim Bailey
Michael Brennan
Olwen Firestone
Trish Hultz
Susan Williams
Dianna DelBianco
David Easter
Caroline Parry
Topics :
time est cost
---- --------
Pgm Staff 140k/yr
Sr Minister 1/1
Assoc Min 1/1
Chrch Adm 1/1
DRE 1/1
Music Coord 1/1
-----
Vol Coord 1/2 20k
Memb Coor 1/2` 20k
S.J. Coord 1/2 20k
Youth Coord 1/2 20k
Adlt RE Coord 1/4 10k
Communication Coord 1/4 10k
Summer Minister 1/4 15k
Intern Min 1/1 15k
Arts Coordinator 1/4 10k
Exec Team - Ministers - DRE - Administrator
Worship/Music Youth Coord Memb Coord/Volunteer
Summer or Adult RE Communication
Intern RE assist Events
bookeeper
custodial
Staffing Models
1) Team Consensus necessary
No Cross supervision
Group Accountability
Who Evaluates?
2) Flying V Task Driven
3) Vertical Top Down
4) Circular Top Down
5) INverted Model -0 Bottom up
6) INdependant Model
Team - Mark is decider ( tie breaker ) or democratic process
Process, Theory, Principles for prioritizing staff hiring
hiring task force?
Deconstruct DRE position?
140,000
500 x -------
3000/12 = $25/mo
How Do We Attract, Integrate, and Retain Youth and Young Adults
Convenor: Gretchen Faulstich
Lydia Delphia
Steve Abbott
David Easter
Susan Garland Williams
Carl Faulstich
We are already attracting young adults
Integrating and retaining are more important
are there 2 groups - those who grew up in the church and those who come on their own?
how we are handling youth whose parents are not involved?
we have worked out "rules"
how do we get the word out?
advertising?
FOCUUS is trying to help with welcoming, integration
we need to prepare for visitors
awareness, welcoming, programming
YASC working on youth retention
covenant group, evening class, more structured youth group
youth overnight - will seek youth input for programming; provide info
we need to see and recognize where youth are already leading
most in congregation don't know what youth are doing
can build from bottom up - youth participating in and then leading worship -> youth involvement on board, committees
childrens circles offer one way for integration(and covenant groups)
some youth drop out as part of rebellion against parents
communication between youth and young adults
young adults 18-35 a wide range with many different interests
college, single, parents
large church can offer more different options
often some ebb and flow in youth participation/leadershop levels
children not always truly welcomed in church events - may cause young adult parents to leave
child care, child programming an issue for young adult parents
many young adults are looking for opportunities to become involved in social justice
youth, also, are interested in social justice
YASC moving in this area
social justice activities could draw in others
structure(visible) in youth programming relieves adult anxiety
YASC can help get youth involved in all-church activities
youth sometimes struggle with navigating the church structure
YASC will have social justice coordinator, newsletter
might young adults like tojoin the youth newsletter effort?
Awarenesses
-we're already attracting young adults. we need awareness, welcoming, programming
-Importance of youth independence and recognition of existing activities(public awareness)
-social justice is a prime attraction for both young adults and youth.
-need to manage adult/parent anxieties re: youth activities. information and training is key
-child care vs. child programming an issue for young adult parents.
Actions
-Talk to DRE Search committee
-YASC communicate with FOCUUS re newsletter
-Some kind of formal communication between young adults and youth - relatively simple - email etc.
How can we be truly welcoming to all—including children and seniors?
Convenor: Gretchen Faulstich
Attendees:
Efforts must involve most of the congregation, become part of the culture
Requires coordination, planning, communication, volunteer recruitment/support, looking at the big picture/lifespan
Staff support could help
Pastoral team has support
Linking people to opportunities (volunteer coordinator?)
Membership big picture (membership coordinator? ministerial priority?
Space for children/families to gather after services
Lots of inviting programming for all ages (needs to be age specific) and intergenerational
Invitation/reminders to practice welcoming behavior
Awareness:
Actions:
Creating Abundance
Convenor: Debra Gray Boyd
Attendees: Gretchen Faulstich, Jim Pinkham, Dan Hronek, Carol Pruiksma, Jeannie Sperling
Your Money or Your Life (read the book? Workshops? Culture shift?)
Thanking /gratitude (without going overboard)
Receiving/awareness of gifts received
Relationships
On going
Personal
Making information accessible and informative
Adult Enrichment Programs to have more description
Create information with other groups in mind
Age
Experience in congregation
Internet accessible computer in building
Abundance in personal will create abundance in congregation
We’re making progress with welcoming which adds to all this
Food on Sundays
Like a Café
Informal
Costs money
Would be a springboard for after service programming
Expand Circle Suppers to year round with larger membership meeting once a month to every 6 weeks
Different frequencies: multi-times a week, weekly, twice a month, etc.
More Socialization
Wear Nametags—personalize nametags at First Friday
Consider one morning and one afternoon service with adult & children’s programming with food in between, maybe café, early morning too (meditation, Sunday School, etc.)
Creating more “Yes, I can do this” volunteer and leadership opportunities
Awareness: How do we create abundance? With volunteers, leaders, staff, time and money.
Actions:
How Do You See the Future of the Church in Terms of
Health, both Personal and Community Health?
Convenor: Marilyn Webster <mari6414@columbus.rr.com>
Attendees:
Parish Nurse Corps
Social action for health care—health insurance, SPAN?
Health Fairs
Free Clinic as a community service
Suicide prevention
Dissemination of health information/resources
Awareness: Health as an issue touches both social justice and pastoral care
Actions:
Name of Church (2nd session)
Convenor: Carol Pruiksma
Attendees: Carol Pruiksma, David Krohn, Susan Williams
“Church” connotes Christian
More relevant names to pair with First UU could include: Community, Congregation, Gathering, Community Gathering, Presence
Or drop “First UU” for a completely new name: Community Congregation of Tolerance, Spirit of Life Congregation (People unfamiliar with Unitarian Universalism are not going to be attracted to or curious about the First Big Long Name Church. )
Pastor instead of Minister
Openspace Technology Workshop
9-29-2007
---------
Session : 2 Effective Communication
Conv : Tom Tucker
Part : Judith McDowell <jmcdoll675@qol.com>
Michael Brennan <micheal@firstuucolumbus.org>
Jim Bailey <jbailey7@columbus.rr.com>
Eve Catus <evecatus@safe-mail.net>
Bill Fullerton <bill.fullerton@sbcglobal.net
Carole Pruiksma <immauutoo@columbus.rr.com>
Mark Merchant <mmerchant@columbus.rr.cmo>
Olwen Firestone <yahoo.com>
Dianna DelBianco <healing-arts@beol.net>
Topics:
- How do I know what is going on?
- Not everyone has computer/web abilities
- How do we communicate effectively w/ those who don't have access?
- Worship feedback group
- expand website
transcripts of sermons
audio sermons
web based discussion group
newsletter upgrade ( color graphics )
- How do we communicate ALL church events to membership ( ie throat singers, krishna
group )
- What should the newsletter be?
- guidelines for respectful use of technology
ket points:
- create a set of policy/procedures or guidelines for respectful use of technology
email/bcc use
- creating norms/values on how to use technology/communicate to entire church
ministers, admin, program staff, members
- increase communication w/in congregation
- expand website
- communicating all events happening on property=
HANDCRAFTING for Community Building, meditation, and spirituality
Covened by Stephanie mesler-evans
Attended by shikha bangia
David Krohn
Portal Activities
Knitting circles
Crafts bizarre
Craft circles
Meditation as part of communal creative process
Prayer Bead creation and meditation
Something about busy hands freeing the spirit and mind
Doing art as a way of touching our own inner divinity
Breathing for art
While doing art
As preparation for doing art
To establish creatively fertile frame of mind
Silence for creation/creative purposes
Cooking classes and eating together
Quilting ministry
Prayer shawls ministry
Subject: All Adult programming – how to enrich improve coordinate & integrate for true lifespan?
Convener: Caroline B Parry
Participants: Debra Boyd, Marilyn Webster, Chas Williams, Trish Hultz, Shikha Bangia
How to go on “beyond” cov. Groups? Ask re “level 1” cbp ?
Spiritual Growth = central
can we offer sp transformation / depth / “higher level”?
Lay ministers?
Examples of uu courses @ Minneapolis, eho river
Somehow coordinate individual mentoring that already goes on in this church
Sp mentoring? Longer programs? Spiritual Guide?
Retreats?
What is “spirituality” to UUs? – service as a component
Annual? Mtg of all leaders / coordinators of all adult programs in first UU
Transform program C? Sermon point?
½ time adult programming staff person
overlap w/other ½ time staff?
Ministerial position? Job description?
Promote courses / facilitators for things like
BYOT “Building your own Theology” etc.
Minister-led
c.f. pastoral team trainings / mtgs
lay leaders
Regular courses on Bible & Standard UU pillars / history – Torah, Koran, Hindu & Buddhist scripture
Move Adult progs on Sundays – weekly standing gps
No present small comm. Gps on “
45 mins? Length? Between services? If so 10:15 – 11? Move 11am service to 11:30? Survey possibilities
Dedicated time for all or adult ss
(parking challenges)
Discussing service theme?
More opps being publicized to be leaders of “spirituality-oriented” groups
Way to serve our church community to be available both on Sundays& Weekdays
Church database of all members skills & interests (c.f. new member info that is no distrib by m’ship comm.)
Green ink = what we can do soon circles
Adult prog to be linked to SJ (& youth)
e.g. – Habitat 4 H or Katrina help
Art of living foundation might link to this have speaker here to model speaker before xmas
Tell Tony – Retreat for all Prog Council members on theme of “sp growth is central”
“Growing spirituality” as another leadership dev course
Year-Round Programming
Convener - Tony Skrabak
Participants - Marilyn Webster mari6414@columbus.rr.com, Jim Bailey jbailey@columbus.rr.com
Key Points
Over the summer we lose:
current members
new members
momentum - activities, committees,
Idea of Adult Religious Education "Sandwich"
9am / 10am / 11am
service/ Adult / service
RE
Actions
We need to ask other congregations that have year-round programming how they do it (same or fewer services, minister in pulpit, RE for children and adults). Do they have good attendance in summer? Is it worth it?
We need to ask our members if they would participate in adult RE and other activities in summer (First Friday, Adult RE, arts, committees)
Other notes
Should we have 1 or 2 services in the summer? How can we afford to have a minister in the pulpit in the summer? Could we use guest ministers and maybe interns?
Should the 9 am service be different from the 11 am service? (all year, not just in the summer)
Idea of adult RE "sandwiched" between the 9 am and 11 am services. People from 9 am service could stay for RE and those from 11 am could come an hour early for adult RE. Choir members could not attend on the weeks they sing.
We lose visitors who are looking for a church in August.
The music program begins year-round this coming year.
Balance the fact that Y-R maintains momentum with the concern that it may cause burnout. Will have to share people resources to prevent burnout..
Expectations are set for the summer by going to one service and suspending meetings. General Assembly and Summer Institute are seen as alternatives to normal church programming -- worship, RE, and committee work.
This priority of this topic is different from others. It is a means rather than an end. It contributes as a means to other ends like diversity and social justice.
Topic: VolunteerCoordinator/ Membership coordinator
Convener: Jim Pinkham
Participants: Michael Brennan, Jim Pinkham, Eve Catus, Trish Hultz
Key points: Participants agreed this may be the next logical position we should create
Most bang for buck - pays for itself quickly
Engages current and new members. Helps with member retention, feeling invested in church community (plugged-in).
We have all heard clear demand for position
Michael Brennan would be willing to supervise this position
Some may think administrator / secretary has this responsibility, but that is not the case.
Some responsibility would include: Keeping skills inventory db, FOLLOWING THRU by connecting volunteers to committees. Coord with membership. Steve K does a lot of this sort of thing with new members now.
Office space may be new desk in front office where large green cabinet is now.
There may be ‘friendly competetion’ between this position and other staff needs such as youth coord and social justice coord.
Actions Emerging: Who: All When: Now What: Convince development, admin council, personell committee, exec members via formal / informal discussions
Trish Hultz will propose to finance & exec about this before next budget cycle.
How Do We Assure Our Fiscal Resources?
The Session discussed the various barriers which stand in the way of our members and friends giving money to the ongoing programs and staffing of the church.
The group came up with several barriers and suggestions:
Continue developing new member pledges.
Develop valuable programming
Connect social justice and spirituality
Promote church as home.
Work on endowment.
Change our story from scarcity to abundance.
Connect with larger community.
Give the people what they want.
Teach people how to receive.
Promote understanding of UU in the larger community.
Convenor: Chas Williams
Open Source Technology Workshop
9-29-2007
---------
Sess : 1
Topic: Performing Arts: For Community Building, Spirituality, & Support + Visibility
Convr: Stephanie Messler-Evans
Parts: Caroline Balderson-Parry <caroline@firstuucolumbus.org>
Kate Power <kate@powerkate.com>
Judith McDowell <jmcdoll675@aol.com
Edie Dreskil <>
David Krohn <davidkrohn@mac.com>
Lydia Delphia <lydiayak@gmail.com>
Mark Merchant <mmerchant@columbus.rr.com>
Wendy Boortz <>
Carol Pruiksma <>
Topics:
- Visibility ( raise platform in worship, line of sight in worship center,
general sensitivity )- Projector ( Childrens Story, other ) - Stories should be told not read. - Can we increase
congregational participation in perf. arts in p?
- Drama Program for kids? ( should we have one? )
- Do we need an arts coordinator?
- Performing arts as an approach to the divine.
- Support for artists ( should we have an artist in residence program? concerts, etc)
- Movement "Choir" ( in worship? )
- Intro to Dances of World Peace
- Sacred Circle Dance? ( Caroline will coordinate w/ Tony )
- Ballroom Dance ( should we organize one for outreach? )
- Community Dance
- Family Dance
- Outreach/Cross Promotion ( welcoming card at the Social Dance tables ).
OPEN SPACE SUNDAY SESSION – September 30, 2007 – Chas Williams, Recorder
Condensation of Five group discussions from oral reports of each of five reporters with
Comments from Chris Kloth
Framework for Discussion:
Diversity
Inclusiveness
Growth
Expansion of Social Justice
Youth programming
Supporting spiritual growth
Accessibility
Visibility
Going green
Increased staffing to support member programming
Portal arts
Common Programming:
Youth programming
Young adult programming
Lifespan programming
Social Justice programming
Chris: Getting to clarity is important to getting things done. How can we move ahead? What are our legitimate areas of common ground? Where we allocate resources has to take into account starting at a small intersection and moving outward. Translating vision into programs requires finding common ground. Keep the book of this Open Space Event right next to you, and don’t put the book away.
Chris: Given what we’ve been talking about, a vision that involves programs and staffing, what have we heard that will give us leverage to move forward? What are some challenges as we try to move ahead?
Leverage:
The 7 principles of our religion
Social justice
Young adults
SYC
Steady growth in pledge commitments
Our location
Close to OSU
Liberal reputation
Our programming
Good number of people to draw from
Energy and excitement
Growth in new member dollars
Competent staff
Congregational talent
Facilities are attractive and clean
Welcoming church (glbt)
Leadership development
Challenges:
Desire for change
Money
Spinning wheels
Negative community perception
Staffing deficits
Overload
Scarcity mentality
Transportation
Prioritizing staffing
Location
Managing volunteers
Technology
Leadership development
Equalizing services
Space is limited
History
Lack of focus
What we’ve done:
Gay pride
Have to ask for more
Successful capital campaign
Ministers well known
Healthy discourse
Being clear in the “ask.”
Holiday appeal
Added staff
BREAD
PFLAG
Music Program
Move to equalize two full services
Accepting risk with land acquisition
Nursery
Covenant groups
Visioning energy
Have increased pledges
Thinking of Volunteer Coordinator
Covenant of Respectful Relations
Chris: Where can we focus our energy? Where do we start? Look for the vision and find the intersections of interests.
Chris: Get clear on what we are trying to be seen as and what staffing do we need. Then, where we do have clarity, take action.
Introduction Chris Kloth, Recorder
The following document is based on the conversations that occurred on the second day of the Open Space Planning Retreat. An earlier document includes the unedited chart summaries from that day.
Overview
The two-hour dialogue was built around five key questions:
What do these common threads & distinctions reveal about our congregation to the community? (internally & externally)
What programming will give life to the vision?
Given the vision of programming and staffing that is emerging, what aspects of the congregation represent points of leverage that will energize and assist in designing and staffing programs to achieve the vision?
What challenges exist inside and outside your congregation that you will need to address (remove or overcome) to achieve your vision?
When has this congregation successfully applied leverage or addressed challenges in ways that may reveal strengths or assets in the congregation that can be the source of learning, inspiration and focus as you move toward your vision?
The full group divided into five smaller groups and discussed the first two questions. Each group reported the results of their dialogue to the full group. Then they identified what they thought were common themes among the 5 reports. Facilitator Chris Kloth shared some thoughts on how to use this information moving forward. The five small groups then discussed the next three questions and shared the results of their work. Kloth finished the session by adding a few more thoughts on use of the information.
In this document the comments on the original charts have been reorganized according to the flow of the five conversations. In addition, common themes from the group reports were added for each question. These notes reflect Kloth’s subjective integration of what was printed and he heard spoken in the groups. He also inserted “Consultant Notes” to supplement the comments he made at the session.
Taken together, these notes represent a starting point. The planning process that follows can use this information to identify potential common ground that can be used to clarify the potential key elements of a vision, what programming may support that vision, what staffing configuration may support that vision of programming and what strengths, opportunities and challenges may need to be addressed to achieve the plan.
What do these common threads & distinctions reveal about our congregation to the community? (Internally & externally)
Group 1
Open, diverse, accepting, welcoming, (many introverts here, in fact)
Taking care of selves > deeper spirituality & caring for those outside
Using energy within to fuel offering “out”
Youth: how to benefit youth and enrich us as adult congregation
Spirituality @ center
Communities within “the community”
Promote communication between/among them
Use staff to enable/support
More paid staff to do structure
Help volunteers to “clone”
Balancing services fully
2 times for getting to know UU
Spread word re: extra parking places
Group 2
Diversity
Welcoming
Inclusive
Accessible
More involvement with social justice in our community
To engage and involve our members
As a well staffed church we will be seen as effective – a strong presence
Nurturing rather than expecting
Better communication & coordination
More opportunity for spiritual growth & development on an ongoing basis
Positive image
Group 3
Name more descriptive & inviting
Welcoming all – living our valuing of each person’s inherent worth
Accepting, appreciating, integrating youth, young adults, seniors…
Involvement in social justice issues – leader, visible
Increased staffing, programming
Known for stewardship & generosity to – resources, recycling, to broader movement, social action
Group 4
More internal than external: not balanced
We’d be seen as a creative community
Uniquely democratic
To visitors, very energetic
Look young, that we care about young people
More inclusive
Group 5
On a journey – No ultimate dogma
Growing faith
Evolving faith
Diverse ministries – well staffed
Challenge fear
Social justice congregation
Rename “church”??
Welcoming diverse populations
Some themes that cross “all” groups in some form
Welcoming/inclusive
Open, diverse, accepting, welcoming, (many introverts here, in fact)
Diversity
Welcoming
Inclusive
Accessible
Welcoming all – living our valuing of each person’s inherent worth
Accepting, appreciating, integrating youth, young adults, seniors…
More inclusive
Welcoming diverse populations
Engaged/connected
Taking care of selves > deeper spirituality & caring for those outside
Communities within “the community”
Promote communication between/among them
Help volunteers to “clone”
To engage and involve our members
Nurturing rather than expecting
Better communication & coordination
We’d be seen as a creative community
Uniquely democratic
To visitors, very energetic
On a journey – No ultimate dogma
Social Justice
Taking care of selves > deeper spirituality & caring for those outside
Using energy within to fuel offering “out”
More involvement with social justice in our community
Involvement in social justice issues – leader, visible
Social justice congregation
Known for stewardship & generosity to – resources, recycling, to broader movement, social action
Staffing
Use staff to enable/support
More paid staff to do structure
Help volunteers to “clone”
Communities within “the community”
Promote communication between/among them
As a well staffed church we will be seen as effective – a strong presence
Increased staffing, programming
Diverse ministries – well staffed
Themes that cross some groups in some form
Youth
Youth: how to benefit youth and enrich us as adult congregation
Accepting, appreciating, integrating youth, young adults, seniors…
Look young…that we care about young people
Spiritual Growth
Spirituality @ center
More opportunity for spiritual growth & development on an ongoing basis
On a journey – No ultimate dogma
Growing faith
Evolving faith
[Consultant’s Note: It is easier to get where you want to go, and to recognize it when you get there, if you can describe it in ways that are broad enough to be inclusive and narrow enough to be actionable. It is important to understand that inclusive does not mean everyone can get all of what they want or that you can address all needs and wants simultaneously…unless you have unlimited resources(people, time, money, energy, etc.). Setting priorities does not require losing anything that is important to you, though you may have to build a foundation before you can achieve some of what you hope for.
In addition, it is useful if a vision has adjectives to bring clarity and richness to the nouns. For example, if the noun is a social justice program, it may be that for such a program to be satisfying when you get there it ought to be described by those involved in it as one that actively includes, engages and connects a broad spectrum of congregants rather than creating a diverse group of projects that create many distinct small groups that seem exclusive. It also seems that you want positive recognition for your leadership role in social justice issues in the larger community. For each key element, explore the deeper elements that will make it more rich and satisfying.]
What programming will give life to the vision?
Group 1
Youth, young adult, social programming
Visual & all arts
Music
Wood dance floor, (contra & social)
Forums & speakers are advertised
Drumming circles
Concerts (free?)
Social Justice < - > BREAD & other church alliances
SYC & RE/Sunday School
Diversity
GLBT & PFLAG groups
Diversity: Seder/Zen
Group 2
Time accessible
Creature comforts
Diversity of offerings
Leadership opportunities
Long term
Short term
Volunteer opportunities
Long term
Short term
Staffing to support members – Volunteer Coordinator
Better communications
Local community outreach
Local partner church
Group 3
Wide range of programming attracts non-members – e.g. contra & other dance, yoga, forums…
Excellent greeting, welcoming, path to membership, etc.
Attracts diverse “audience”, some join
Visible, vibrant social justice work involves most in congregation
RE truly life span
Group 4
That supports positive life changes
More focused Social Justice that is spirit-driven and teaches skills
More arts activities that are
Spirit driven
Open to the larger community
e.g. music, theater, dance, hand-crafts
More, better & more reliable youth and young adult programming
Group 5
Large Church – staffing
Worship celebrations – additional staff
Music minister
Campus minister (Young people)
Summer minister
Youth Programs
Youth ministry – youth coordinator
Social justice coordinator
Art programs – arts coordinator
Education
Global Community
Spirituality
Transportation
Seniors
Youth
Themes that cross some groups in some form
Programming
Youth, young adult, social programming
Youth Programs
More, better & more reliable youth and young adult programming
Sunday School
Art programs – arts coordinator
More activities that are …
Open to the larger community
e.g. music, theater, dance, hand-crafts
Visual & all arts
Music
Wood dance floor, (contra & social)
Forums & speakers are advertised
Drumming circles
Concerts (free?)
Wide range of programming attracts non-members – e.g. contra & other dance, yoga, forums…
Excellent greeting, welcoming, path to membership, etc.
Attracts diverse “audience”, some join
Social Justice < - > BREAD & other church alliances
Visible, vibrant social justice work involves most in congregation
More focused Social Justice that is spirit-driven and teaches skills
Staffing
Staffing to support members – Volunteer Coordinator
Youth coordinator
Social justice coordinator
Art programs – arts coordinator
Engagement/Involvement